This Is Why the Detractors Hate Your Minimum Viable Product

Before you test the market, let’s make sure your product isn’t “impracticable”

Joe Procopio


image by katemangostar on freepik

Last month, I wrote a piece about Minimum Viable Product (MVP) development and why the haters hate it.

TL;DR: As an entrepreneur and a product leader, I bring new products and features to market at a pretty solid clip, including a massive one about ten minutes before I sat down to write this. I almost always launch these new products after testing their market viability with an MVP.

The main argument I hear against MVP development is that it hurts the software ecosystem by allowing flawed product to go to market at an ever increasing rate.

Here’s the problem I have with that criticism:

MVP isn’t about the needs of the existing market

There’s a misconception that those of us who develop and release MVPs are bringing a known quantity to a known market. That isn’t the case at all. If we were doing that, we’d be internal IT engineers, not entrepreneurs.

A true entrepreneur is attempting to bring innovation to market, not a commodity. And when you’re trying to do something that’s never been done before, you’re not so much finding a market as making one.

Entrepreneurs use MVPs to find product-market fit

You basically have two options to get an answer on viability before you attempt to carve out a new market for a new product.

  1. Spend a lot of money.
  2. Build an MVP.

So those MVP detractors are either folks that can easily get their hands on a lot of money or they’ve never created a market.

But that’s cool. I’m going to help the detractors here as much as I’m going to help the entrepreneurs and innovators. Because the detractors are indeed correct about one thing:

The true test of viability isn’t whether or not your product works.

It’s also not whether or not you can sell that product to a paying customer. True viability comes down to whether or not that product can establish market fit.



Joe Procopio

I'm a multi-exit, multi-failure entrepreneur. NLG pioneer. Building & GROWERS. Write at and More at