How Successful Startups Avoid Selling To People Who Aren’t Buying

Discover, define, and mine your market to find customer gold

Image for post
Image for post

Why do some new products fly off the shelves while others have sales cycles that extend out for months?

Selling any product is a mixture of art and science, but selling a new product with no track record from a company with no reputation — that requires a science all its own.

Every new product is different, of course, but one commonality I see among successful startups is an unwillingness to market and sell to people who aren’t buying. As simple as that sounds, it’s a trap entrepreneurs fall into over and over again.

In 20 years of rolling out new products and selling into dozens of different markets, I’ve learned that to sell a new product, repeatedly and sustainably, you have to refuse to twist the customer’s arm.

Here’s how to do that.

Your goal is NOT to sell as much product as you can

I’m going to buck conventional wisdom here a little bit and tell you that all of the advice you hear about always-be-selling and always-be-closing and throwing enough shit at a wall for some to stick — this isn’t for you.

I’m not disparaging those tactics, per se, just letting you know they’re not intended for an entrepreneur selling a new product.

They say that every buying decision is made almost immediately; some will even peg that limit at the first 60 seconds. One of the reasons a lot of entrepreneurs hate selling is because they think that this 60 seconds has something to do with them. It does not. That first 60 seconds is all about the product and the pitch.

In fact, confident salespeople might tell you they exude confidence because they’re great at selling. But in their darkest hours, they’ll admit that their confidence comes from having a great product, an amazing message, and selling into the right market.

Those first two things are far easier to change than that last one. So let’s start with the hardest part first.

Discover your market

Who would buy this?

That’s a question you should be asking from the moment your startup idea pops into your brain. I can’t tell you how many fully-developed products get put in front of me with fully-formed marketing materials, and I have no idea who would buy the product and why.

And when I ask, the answer I usually get is: “Anyone!” or some slight derivation. That answer could be correct, but it requires twisting an awful lot of arms.

A startup finds product-market fit by either adjusting the product to meet the market or by moving to a new market, one that finds more value in the product. The latter is risky, because the problem/solution equation usually lies within a specific market. Move away from that market, and the problem is likely not as painful, and the solution is probably not as valuable.

So every decision you make during the first X months of the life of your product should be rooted in that question: Who would buy this?

Will your decision widen your market? Will it water down the value-proposition? Will it increase value? Will it bring more complexity?

Usually, I don’t know where my product-market fit is until those X months are over. And I use X because sometimes X is 3, and sometimes X is 36. But I can assure you this: X is never zero. I don’t define my market; I discover it.

Develop traction in that market

A lot of entrepreneurs think of the search for traction as the exercise of proving the product they have fits the market they’re targeting. That’s actually an exercise in futility, because you don’t prove product-market fit, you develop it.

Once you’ve determined your target market, you can address product-market fit by dipping your toe into that market with your messaging. One of the lessons I keep having to learn is that there is no such thing as too few words in an introduction of that messaging.

The trick is to use as few words as possible, but the exact right few words.

Figuring that out takes time and thought and experimentation. Remember, at this early stage with your product and your company, you’re asking your customers to help you develop your product-market fit, not conform to it.

In other words, you don’t need to twist the customer’s arm, you need to change what they’re looking at or how they’re looking at it. Readdress your product, reinvent your messaging. Develop traction.

Start mining that traction for all its worth

One of the reasons I’ve grown to hate marketing and selling to people who aren’t buying is that every minute I’m doing that is a minute I’m not finding traction and mining that traction.

You can either spend three months selling into a market with little traction, or you can spend three months finding product-market fit and building traction with little sales.

The next three months that follow the latter scenario are going to be much better than the three months that follow the former scenario. Because the three months that follow the former scenario will look exactly like the prior three months.

When you do find traction, drop everything and put all of your effort into building on those sales to find more sales.

Make that mining more efficient

Even when you’re putting all your efforts into repeatable, sustainable selling, you’ll still need to be experimenting to reduce your sales cycle and increase your margins. This will make the difference between sawtooth growth and scaled growth.

Keep track of each process step, costs, and time. Become more efficient, reduce waste in the sales cycle, and automate whenever possible. Ideally, you’ll want to break down your sales cycle into mini-cycles, measure those process steps, and spend time making each one more productive. It could be as simple as reducing the number of fields in a customer form, or the number of pages in a customer contract.

Most importantly, do not get caught flat-footed when this traction wave ends, because it will. So you should not only still be asking, “Who would buy this?” You also need to be asking, “Who else would buy this?”

Expect that mine to dry up and prepare to repeat

As that traction wave is ending, you’ll suddenly find yourself in danger of marketing and selling to people who aren’t buying all over again. This is your last chance to avoid the mistake of believing that something will turn around and all the numbers will start going up again.

Spend less time on the strategies and tactics that aren’t working and begin exploring again. Find a new market, a new angle, update your product or how you sell it. The beauty of this is you can use the same steps you used to find your original product-market fit; only this time, it’s version two.

That’s a virtuous cycle, and if there’s one thing I do love about sales and marketing, it’s selling into a virtuous cycle.

Hey! If you found this post actionable or insightful, please consider signing up for my newsletter at joeprocopio.com so you don’t miss any new posts. It’s short and to the point.

This post was originally published in Built In.

Written by

I’m a multi-exit, multi-failure entrepreneur. Building Precision Fermentation & Teaching Startup. Sold Automated Insights & ExitEvent. More at joeprocopio.com

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store